
The Holdovers is directed by Alexander Payne a director who while I’m not a die hard fan of his work I can still appreciate how great his films are (with the exception of Downsizing I still to this day have no idea what that was).
The Holdovers is quite possibly the most human film of 2023 and what I mean by that is it’s a huge character study that really studies the many emotions people feel during Christmas time. The film is also quite possibly the most wholesome rated r film you will ever see in almost every shot there’s heart and soul being poured into it.
The natural place to start is the performances, Paul Giamatti is the lead who plays Paul Hunham a curmudgeonly history teacher who teaches at a New England boarding school and has to chaperone some students over Christmas break. Hunham starts out as your traditional teacher character, the teacher that students do not get along with at all. But slowly through the course of the film we get to see a ton of development in Hunham, Giamatti’s performance is really what makes his character he effortlessly balances being comedic and having more dramatic moments as well. Whenever Giamatti and Da’Vine Joy-Randolph are on screen together that’s when some of the film’s best moments occur. The two truly bounce off of each other incredibly well and show their range as performers.
Da’Vine Joy Randolph is truly incredible here, much like Giamatti through the course of the film we slowly but surely get to learn about her character. Her chemistry between the cast is masterful she plays a mother named Mary who just lost her son in the Vietnam War, the emotion and pain we see from her conversations with the other characters and her actions is truly some of the most powerful moments from a film this year.
A performance that I feel is not getting talked about quite enough is Dominic Sessa which the film happens to be his first performance and it’s quite a powerful one. He plays a student named Angus who starts out as your typical student character that doesn’t get along with anyone, but much like Paul Giamatti’s character slowly evolves over the course of the film. When the film really starts to examine Sessa’s character that’s when you truly get some hard hitting moments, his parents don’t want him home from Christmas and he really doesn’t have anything planned out after boarding school. Where will he go? What will his future be? These are questions that almost immediately come to the viewer’s mind when learning about his life.
Eventually the film focuses on Paul, Mary and Angus three completely different people who are at different stages in their lives. Paul is a college professor who really doesn’t get a long with a lot of people, Mary as I said before is grieving because of the loss of her son and Angus has a very troubling family life. But in a lot of ways the three really help each other and it’s honestly what makes this film so great. The natural human connection especially during the holidays, the want to help another person out or at the very least understand where they are coming from or what their situation is. It’s beautiful moments like these that really hit the viewer hard in the heart.
The film itself really feels like a time capsule from the 70s, from the look of the film to how it’s filmed. Cinematographer Eigil Bryld does an excellent job of really giving this warm Christmas feeling to how it’s shot, you truly feel like you’re there during a Christmas in the 70s. Most of all though is the film has the feel of a Christmas card that maybe one of your family members or friends gave you. You stored it away and one day you open it up again, it’s a sense of nostalgia that cannot be beaten it honestly brings you to tears because of how beautiful the memories really are.
Lastly there’s the writing and direction which are both just phenomenal, the script from David Hemingson is truly touching and Alexander Payne’s direction is very natural. Something both Hemingson and Payne clearly wanted the viewer to know is that they both truly love these characters and want the viewer to see themselves through these characters and the two really accomplished that incredibly well. You truly feel the love in every single moment during the film, whether it be a comedic moment or a dramatic one there’s always some sort of love.
The Holdovers is one of the best films of the year and one of the most powerful ones as well, it’s a feel good film that is so much more than just being positive. It’s about connecting with others, loving others and helping each other however we can.
The Holdovers is available on all VOD platforms.
10/10 A+








