
The Super Mario Galaxy Movie is directed by Aaron Horvath and Michael Jelenic both of which previously directed The Super Mario Bros. Movie (2023) and the former also directing Teen Titans Go! To The Movies (2018). The Super Mario Galaxy Movie serves as a sequel to The Super Mario Bros. Movie (2023).
After The Super Mario Bros. Movie (2023) was a quick and easy success it was almost immediately announced that a sequel was being made and it would be based around Super Mario Galaxy an incredibly beloved video game for the Wii that I have plenty of fond memories of playing when the Nintendo Wii first came out. It’s a fantastic game that still holds up incredibly well to this day. Luckily the film isn’t all bad, but there are some very glaring flaws and a few parts that are on the very disappointing side of things.
The voice cast does a pretty great job, particularly Donald Glover as Yoshi and Glen Powell as Fox McCloud. While yes Glover only ever says Yoshi or the typical Yoshi noises, I do think he brings the charm from the games to the big screen, this is one of those things where it’s sort of hard to really pin down. But if you watch the film and have played the games you will know exactly what I mean. Glen Powell’s voice just fits like a glove for Fox McCloud, he has the charisma and charm to back it up. He’s going for a Han Solo type of angle here and due to Powell’s smooth and strong delivery it works here.
Chris Pratt notably does a better job as Mario, It does feel like he’s getting a lot more familiar with the role so he is slowly but surely growing into it. There are some hiccups here and there but for the most part he does great, Charlie Day as Luigi is great, Jack Black as Bowser is just as entertaining and Anya Taylor-Joy as Peach is solid. Benny Safdie as Bowser Jr. however is incredibly unfitting and does not work. I get what they were trying to go for here with this older sounding version of the character. But the dialogue and tone of the movie just doesn’t match here at all with Safdie’s voice.
The animation is pretty solid here, if there is one thing this film does a very good job with it’s making it seem like you the viewer jumped into a video game and going on the adventure with Mario, Luigi and Yoshi. It’s much larger in scale than the previous film and that’s partly due to how detailed the animation really is, it’s a very well done recreation of a Super Mario video game. Everywhere you go there’s little sound effects, music bits or characters from this franchise’s history, it’s a huge celebration in that regard.
The main problem comes in with the movie’s take on Super Mario Galaxy…it just does not really feel like a Galaxy movie. Sure the movie takes place largely in space, it has some of the very recognizable songs from the game and even has some of the characters. But Rosalina (played by Brie Larson) for example gets a very limited amount of screen time and is basically a damsel in destress for a majority of the movie. I understand that even in the source material Rosalina did not do a whole lot during Mario’s adventure, however the advertising and the way this movie was being presented would have you believe Rosalina would be given a whole lot more to do. It kind of just seems like a very odd choice to keep one of the source material’s most memorable parts on the bench, it’s a shame to because Brie Larson gives a great performance.
Outside of Rosalina, the rest of the movie does have the DNA of the source material there. But never goes far enough with it, there is a lot of jumping around that is never fully able to have a strong grip on the atmosphere that Galaxy had. I do think the writing has its strong moments, but ultimately it is just very one note. It goes through way too many ideas in a short amount of time, there absolutely needed to be some breathing room for the movie.
Overall The Super Mario Galaxy Movie isn’t bad, it’s a heavily flawed movie yet still a decent amount of fun. It is certainly a step down from its predecessor but I do think fans will get enough out of this one.
The Super Mario Galaxy Movie is available on all VOD platforms.
6/10 C+








