
The Rule Of Jenny Pen is directed by James Ashcroft director of Coming Home In The Dark (2021).
I really liked the disturbing and incredibly dark atmosphere of Ashcroft’s previously film Coming Home In The Dark (2021), so I was excited to see what he would do next and luckily The Rule Of Jenny Penn continues to show that Ashcroft is a director to keep an eye on. While there are some writing issues with its characters and the movie goes on for a bit longer than it should, there’s some strong performances and really great atmosphere building that make the rest home setting incredibly chilling.
John Lithgow and Geoffrey Rush are what really make this film work as well as it does, this is yet another film from this year that has two fantastic actors going all out with their acting. Geoffrey Rush plays Stefan Mortensen a man who’s trying to recover from a stroke he had but John Lithgow who plays Dave Crealy who has a creepy puppet named Jenny Pen terrorizes this man as well as the other residents.
Geoffrey Rush does such a fantastic job at playing someone who is truly scared, his interactions with John Lithgow are filled with atmosphere and him being confined into a rest home with seemingly no room for escape is truly terrifying and it’s all shown through his body language and speech that gets more and more scared as the film goes on. His performance really does a fascinating job of capturing the atmosphere, I do wish we got a bit more meat character writing wise with Stefan but there is this sense of wanting to get justice against what it takes to protect himself from everything going on in the film.
On the other side you have John Lithgow who is both humorous and terrifying, it’s such a hauntingly well done mix of the two thanks to Lithgow’s talent as an actor. The scenes of him just talking to Jenny Pen as if she is another person in the room starts out as being funny and could be written off as someone being cuckoo, but as we see more of Dave’s actions and to the point where he genuinely believes what he is saying the more haunting it gets. Dave has this god complex that he uses to intimidate the other residents and Stefan, he uses Jenny Pen as some sort of enforcer to make demands some of which makes the viewer squirm. Lithgow paints the portrait of a man who is quite clearly off his rocker as well as a nasty man who has spent too long in one place.
The atmosphere combined with the rest home setting is very well done, much like what we got in Ashcroft’s previous film we get a thrilling and quite unsettling feel as soon as the movie gets going with its plot. The movie isn’t as disturbing as Coming Home In The Dark (2021) was but that’s not necessary here as the film does a great job at moving the story along and just having engaging back-and-forths between Lithgow and Rush, the rest home setting also have the dark feel of no escape something that is constantly felt throughout the film and ultimately builds into the final moments of the end result.
The main flaw is mostly some of the writing as well as going on for a bit too long, the writing at times does admittedly feel a bit on the generic side of things. Mostly from the side characters who while also turn in some great performances don’t really have many strong moments and are very much overshadowed by Lithgow and Rush, there were also points where the film felt like it was reaching it’s conclusion only to continue going on which did make certain scenes feel more like padding rather than moving the story forward or reaching a natural conclusion.
With that being said The Rule Of Jenny Pen is still a pretty solid film that I recommend giving a go! If you like one location films you will definitely like this one. I say check this one out for Lithgow and Rush’s performances alone!
The Rule Of Jenny Pen is currently in theaters and releases on Shudder tomorrow!
7/10 B








