
I Know What You Did Last Summer is directed by Jennifer Kaytin Robinson director of Someone Great (2019) and Do Revenge (2020). The film is the fourth installment in the I Know What You Did Last Summer franchise and serves as a sequel to I Still Know What You Did Last Summer (1998).
In the age of the classic slasher franchises such as Halloween and Scream getting legacy sequels it was a matter of time until a franchise that while is not as recognizable still has its fans gets its turn. The I Know What You Did Last Summer series never really did it for me, while I do like the I Know What You Did Last Summer (1997) along with its sequel I Still Know What You Did Last Summer (1998) I’m not as in love with them as some other people are. I’ll Always Know What You Did Last Summer (2006) is flat out one of the worst films I’ve ever seen so let’s just skip talking about that, especially since this new film ignores that one (gee I wonder why.)
This new film is pretty solid, it shares a lot of what I did like or appreciate from the first film plus adding its own flavor into the mix. The film does have a lot of hiccups but in between the film’s flaws is something quite fun and surprisingly takes some swings where even if not all of them fully work, you cannot help but respect it for even attempting them.
I know I often say this a lot in my reviews but the cast is what really brings this film together and makes it work as well as it does. Madelyn Cline, Chase Sui Wonders and Sarah Pidgeon are far and away the standouts who really give such fun and investing performances. Chase Sui Wonders works incredibly well as the main protagonist we follow and her character Ava’s bond with Danica (played by Madelyn Cline) is genuinely heartwarming at times as well decently comedic, there’s a layer of warmth here that we do not often see in some slasher films so it’s a a breath of fresh air.
Which leads to Madelyn Cline who I believe to be the standout, she’s genuinely funny and really captures the spirit of some of the campiness that is going on around her with the atmosphere. She has this nice balance of dramatic and comedic moments that doesn’t overshadow each other, she works especially well with the rest of the cast having these fun exchanges that work so well in the context of each scene. She’s able to quickly switch from being serious to comedic or vice versa without making it feel forced or awkward.
Sarah Pidgeon is really fun here as well, she might not be in it as much as Wonders and Cline but she still turns in a great performance that does leave a lasting impression by the end of the film. It’s also worth noting that Gabbriette Bechtel gives a fun performance as well, she is not in the film for very long but that doesn’t stop her from being such a fun part of the film.
The writing is a bit of a mixed bag, when the film is focusing on the newcomers the film shines and builds up the mystery of who this mysterious killer can be. The legacy character portion of the film is not anything bad, it’s great to see Jennifer Love Hewitt and Freddie Prinze Jr. return and they do a pretty solid job acting wise. But I do think that when the film focuses on them it’s a bit on the weaker side…at first. That’s until a huge swing at the end of the film that I’m obviously not going to spoil happens. The huge swing in question either going to piss off fans of the series or is going to make you surprised to the point where you love it. It’s something I genuinely was not expecting and is largely what makes the film quite memorable.
Jennifer Kaytin Robinson does quite a solid job in the director’s chair, it’s clear she wanted to focus on building some of these characters like Ava and Danica and explore their bonds not in this super in depth way. But in a way that is just enough for the viewer to care for them and what they are going through, while there are some very forced social media references that can potentially take you out of the film. What Robinson is able to get out of the characters is quite great and gives the film personality.
Everything else here is pretty alright, the kills are nothing to write home about (besides a certain kill towards the beginning of the film) but they are decently fun for what they are. The cinematography from Elisha Christian has some quite beautiful moments that actually do recapture the feel of the first film.
Overall I Know What You Did Last Summer is a decent addition to the franchise. The cast, the direction and the swings the film makes are enough to push this one to the finish line and to recommend giving it a watch!
I Know What You Did Last Summer is currently in theaters.
6/10 C+








